A Comprehensive Guide to the 4 Best Natural Sweeteners

A Comprehensive Guide to the 4 Best Natural Sweeteners

By EXO Team on Jul 02, 2019

Looking for a healthy natural sweetener, without the nasty aftertaste and side effects? Check out our guide to the top four natural sweeteners.

Share Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Icon Mailto graphic image

Humans are hard wired for sugar. Fruit, pastries, soda pop – it starts when sugar molecules bind to taste receptors on your tongue. Then, there’s a sense of pleasure, as your brain lights up with a flood of dopamine and serotonin. And, for the moment, sugar is amazing.

But, here’s the kicker. Eventually that sugar rush comes crashing down, contributing to cavities, obesity, and diabetes. Yet, still you crave the sweet stuff.

The problem is that we have an evolutionary mismatch.

The Ancestral Root to Our Sweet Tooth 

At one point in time, the taste for sugar kept us alive. Our distant primate relatives would swing in the forest canopy, searching for sweet, ripened fruit, which provided more energy and water than bitter, unripened fruit. Bitter or sour tastes could signal poisonous or inedible foods. So, the preference for sweet, sugary foods developed as an evolutionary trait to keep our ancestors alive.

But this same evolutionary trait that helped our ancestors survive for thousands of years, today puts us at risk for multiple chronic diseases, and shortened longevity.

That’s because, although our palates have remained likely unchanged for hundreds of thousands of years, our culture and agricultural practices have changed dramatically over the past 100 years. We no longer move throughout the day, hunting and foraging for food. Instead, sugar is cheap, plentiful, and easily added to foods ad nauseam.

Today, we live in a very different world than our ancestors, a world in which tastes can be deceiving. Rather than seeking out sweet foods for survival, sweetness might better signal caution given the abundance of sugar.

Fortunately, for the cautious connoisseur, there are a variety of natural sweeteners without sugar that you can use to trick your taste buds, while minimizing the metabolic effects of sugar.  

The Best Natural Sweeteners Without Sugar 

The following is a list of the top-tier natural sweeteners, with a brief description of their benefits, and taste profile. If you’re having trouble tempering your sweet tooth, try one of the following alternatives. 

Stevia

Stevia is one of the most popular natural sweeteners on the market, and it comes from the leaves of a South American plant called stevia rebaudiana. Stevia is about 300 hundred times sweeter than sugar, so if you’re using it as a substitute, start small. If a recipe calls for 1 cup of sugar, 1 tsp of Stevia will probably be fine. However, you’ll want to follow the manufacturers recommendations, since each stevia product can vary by brand.

Calories and Carbs in Stevia

Stevia, in its pure form has zero carbohydrates, and zero calories. However, most stevia products combine stevia leaf extract with other ingredients such as dextrose, maltodextrin, erythritol or other fillers to help reduce the sweetness of stevia and mimic the taste of sugar. So, if you’re using a stevia-based substitute that’s combined with dextrose or maltodextrin you’ll still be getting some carbs and calories, and your sugar substitute will still influence your blood sugar.

Without sugar additives, Stevia will not increase blood sugar and one study has shown it can actually decrease blood sugar for those with type 2 diabetes, after a meal. At low doses, studies also suggest stevia can have anti-inflammatory and anti-oxidative benefits.

Stevia Digestibility

As for digestibility, most people tolerate stevia well, unless the product has been mixed with a sugar alcohol like maltitol. In that case, people often experience diarrhea, and bloating.

Stevia Taste

It’s hard to find a sweetener that’s a perfect taste replacement for sugar, and some people find that stevia has a metallic and bitter after-taste. Since it’s about 300 hundred times sweeter than sugar, it’s also a bit too easy to over sweeten things by accident.

Monk Fruit

This is a sweetener of several monikers. It’s also sometimes called lo han guo, or Buddha fruit, but it originates from the vines of the siraitia grosvenorii plant, which is native to Southeast Asia. It’s first recorded usage was with monks living in 13th century China, where it’s been used for centuries as a traditional medicine, and low-calorie sweetener.

The sweetener comes from the pulp and juice inside this small brown gourd. Juice is collected then dried into a concentrated powder that, like Stevia, is 200-300 times sweeter than sugar.

Calories and Carbs in Monk Fruit

Monk fruit naturally does contain fructose and glucose, but when it’s processed the sugars are removed, and the remaining extract contains mogroside. Mogroside is the compound responsible for monk fruit’s no-calorie sweetness.

Since monk fruit contains zero sugars, and zero calories, it does not increase blood sugar levels. In a study done on diabetic mice, mogroside extract actually decreased blood sugar levels, and increased HDL, the “good” cholesterol. The decrease in blood sugar levels could be due to mogroside’s insulin stimulating effects, although this has not been tested in humans.

Like stevia, monk fruit is often blended with sweeteners. So, if your using it as a sugar substitute, check your label to see what they’re mixing it with. If it’s dextrose or maltodextrin, it will cause an increase in blood sugar. It’s also often combined with erythritol, which will not affect blood sugar.

Monk Fruit Digestibility

Monk fruit, by itself, typically does not cause people many belly aches. But, as suggested previously, you need to look at the label to see what other ingredients it may be mixed with. If it’s mixed with a sugar alcohol like xylitol or maltitol, it can cause digestive issues like diarrhea, gas and bloating.

Monk Fruit Taste

Most people find monk fruit to have a fruity taste and describe it as less bitter than other natural sweeteners, like Stevia. Like most sugar-free sweeteners though, some people do notice a slight aftertaste. But, overall, it tends to have a milder taste and is often preferred to other more popular sugar substitutes.

Keep in mind, like stevia, monk fruit is extremely sweet. So, start small and adjust to find the appropriate level of sweetness.

Erythritol

Erythritol is a sugar alcohol that occurs naturally in some fruits, vegetables, and fermented foods. In 1950 it was found in fermented blackstrap molasses, and then commercialized as a natural sweetener in Japan in the 1990s.

Erythritol is produced by hydrolyzing corn starch into glucose, and then fermenting glucose using yeast or fungus.

Unlike stevia or monk fruit, erythritol is less sweet than sugar. It’s about 70% as sweet as sugar, so it’s easier to substitute erythritol for sugar in a 1:1 ratio, without overwhelming your taste buds. For this reason, it’s often used in low-carb baking. It also often combined with monk fruit and stevia, since it’s less sweet, and has a similar metabolic effect.

Calories and Carbs in Erythritol

Erythritol is not zero calorie, but it is low calorie, and lower than other sugar alcohols. For example, erythritol has about 0.24 calories per gram, which is significantly less than the sugar alcohol xylitol, which has 2.4 calories per gram. This is compared to table sugar’s 4 calories per gram.

Since erythritol is a sugar alcohol, it’s technically categorized as a carbohydrate. However, sugar alcohols are indigestible by the human body, because we lack the enzyme to break them down. The result is that there are no net carbs in erythritol, so it doesn’t raise blood sugar or insulin levels. One study has shown that 90% of ingested erythritol is absorbed and then excreted in the urine, without any affect on blood glucose, or insulin.

Erythritol Digestibility

Most sugar alcohols are known for causing stomach discomfort, gas, bloating, and diarrhea. That’s because the body can’t break down sugar alcohols, so they pass into the colon unchanged. Then, when they get to the colon, microbiota break them down via fermentation, thus producing gas as a byproduct. 

Erythritol is different from most sugar alcohols. For starters, only about 10% of it even reaches the colon, because 90% of it is absorbed into the bloodstream. Secondly, erythritol has shown resistance to microbiota fermentation. The result is that erythritol tends to lack the digestive symptoms associated with most sugar alcohols. Although, some people do report digestive symptoms occurring when erythritol is consumed in high quantities, most people don’t experience any discomfort with normal usage.

So, just show some restraint, and you should be okay.

Erythritol Taste

Most people find that erythritol has a very similar taste to sugar and find the two indistinguishable. It even caramelizes like sugar. However, the main difference in terms of taste is that erythritol can have a cooling effect in the mouth, similar to mint.

Allulose

Allulose is one of the newest low-calorie sweeteners on the market. With the same taste and texture of sugar, and no after taste, it’s rising in popularity.

Allulose is considered a “rare sugar” because it’s naturally found in small amounts in a limited number of foods, like figs, wheat, and raisins. It’s also called D-psicose, and it has the same chemical makeup of fructose, but a slightly different structure. As a result, it maintains a similar taste quality to sugar, without the same metabolic effect because, like erythritol, our bodies are unable to metabolize allulose for energy.

To produce allulose, manufacturers take fructose from corn and other plants, and then expose it to an enzyme that converts the fructose structure into D-psicose.

Calories and Carbs in Allulose

Allulose carries about one tenth the calories of table sugar, or about 0.2-0.4 calories per gram. Since it’s indigestible, the net carbs are also zero. Allulose is similar to erythritol because it is primarily absorbed into the blood stream and it does not raise blood glucose or insulin. Studies suggest it has the potential to lower the glycemic response to maltodextrin, and reduce the elevation in blood sugar that occurs after a meal.

Allulose Digestibility 

In small amounts, allulose should not cause any digestive discomforts, which makes it a favorable sugar substitute to sugar alcohols like xylitol, and maltitol. If consumed in large quantities, it can cause bloating and gas however. Also, since it’s a relatively new natural sweetener, there is little research that’s been done on the long-term effects of allulose, and how it may affect the microbiome.

Allulose Taste

Allulose is a favorable natural sweetener because it has a remarkably similar flavor to sugar, without any funky after taste. It’s also about 70% as sweet as table sugar, so serves as a pretty simple sugar substitute, that you can trade spoon for spoon, while tapering your sweet tooth.

Runner-Up Sugar Substitutes & Natural Sweeteners 

There are so many sugar substitutes available, that it’s hard to discuss each of them in detail. That’s why we’ve tried to narrow them down to include the four highest quality sweeteners above.

However, there are some popular sugar substitutes that you’re likely to encounter, and not all of them are natural. The following are a few sweeteners that we don’t consider to be top tier. These sugar substitutes each have at least one drawback, and in some cases aren’t considered “natural”. But we think they’re worth being aware of.

Maltitol 

Like, erythritol, maltitol is also a sugar alcohol. And, it’s often added to alternative sweeteners like stevia and monk fruit. But, unfortunately, maltitol has several drawbacks compared to other natural sweeteners.

Maltilol is a low-calorie sweetener, but unlike erythritol, it has a high glycemic index and will cause a spike in blood sugar. It’s also highly fermented by microbiota in the colon, and frequently causes stomach discomfort due to gas, bloating, and diarrhea.

Xylitol 

Another sugar alcohol, xylitol doesn’t spike blood sugar or insulin, which makes it a decent alternative to sugar. However, like maltitol, it has the unfortunate side effect of causing gas, bloating and diarrhea. Most people report less severe gastric issues with xylitol, compared to maltitol, but let’s be serious… any amount of diarrhea is too much.

In small doses, xylitol is also toxic to cats and dogs.

As far as sugar alcohols go, you’re best off sticking with erythritol, which has the benefits of sugar alcohols, with fewer side effects.

Sucralose 

Sucralose is the key ingredient of the artificial sweetener Splenda. First of all, it is not a natural sweetener. And, although sucralose has zero calories, and no effect on blood sugar, it’s combined with dextrose and maltodextrin in Splenda. That means in its most common form it can spike blood sugar and contribute to total calories.

Sucralose is also unstable for cooking, because it begins to break down and interact with other ingredients like glycerol, which can then produce harmful substances.

Tagatose

Tagatose is a simple sugar that’s metabolized differently than glucose. It’s about 90% as sweet as table sugar, and it has a much lower glycemic index. However, the only drawback with tagatose is that it does cause a slight increase in blood glucose and insulin. It’s also fairly difficult to find compared to other natural sweeteners, so tends to be more expensive as well.

What’s Your Favorite Sugar Alternative?

Do you have a favorite sweetener from the list above? Or, did we leave your favorite one out?

Everyone has a different taste preference. And, we’d love to know more about yours.

Share your thoughts in the comments.

Protien Bars

NEW SUSTAINABLE HIGH-PROTEIN BARS AS UNIQUE AS YOU

3 delicious flavors. 16 grams of protein. Nutritious and Sustainable.

Try Now!

Maximum Nutrition – Minimum Resources